Let's analyze the basic elements of the
situation. If you knew that declarer had three hearts, you should play
the ten. Declarer will win his honor, and eventually lose the other two.
He will not be able to reach the dummy, and the ace and king of clubs will
be so much wastepaper. Wouldn't that be nice?
If you knew that declarer had two hearts
(necessarily headed by either the queen or the jack), you should win the
ace. Then you need to return a club. That will cut declarer's link to the
dummy, so that he cannot score two hearts and two clubs even if he holds
the queen of hearts.
Let's see how various lead agreements might
provide the information you need to get this right:
The old-fashioned standard agreement is to
lead fourth best. Some add the proviso that fourth best guarantees
an honor in the suit led. Unfortunately, if one is dealt three to an
honor, one must also lead low. So if partner leads a low heart, you cannot
determine whether he has three or four, and thus you can be successful on
this deal only by making an inspired guess.
The modern expert treatment is to lead
third highest from an even number and lowest from an odd number. That's a
little more informative, but it doesn't clear up the ambiguity on this
deal because partner's lead would be the eight. The eight is consistent
with partner's holding being
♥J98
or
♥J98x.
You should play the ten in the first case, or the ace in the second. But
you can't tell which is the actual case.
Only parity leads solve the problem. A
parity lead is simply the highest one can spare from an even number, the
lowest from an odd number. That subtle difference is sufficient to resolve
this deal. Partner leads the nine, which you can recognize as being from a
four-card holding. Win the ace and return a club.
What happened when the hand was actually played?
Parity leads were not in use, and East guessed wrongly to play the ten. Declarer won the queen,
then played two rounds of clubs discarding his other heart. He next played
the ace, king, and a third diamond, and the defenders were cooked. It
didn't matter whether West trumped the second diamond. The defense could
only score one diamond trick and two trump tricks. Contract made.
| |
North |
|
| |
♠43 |
|
| |
♥K63 |
|
| |
♦1075 |
|
| |
♣AK863 |
|
|
West |
|
East |
|
♠Q976 |
|
♠10 |
|
♥J982 |
|
♥A1075 |
|
♦2 |
|
♦QJ986 |
|
♣Q542 |
|
♣J97 |
| |
South |
|
| |
♠AKJ852 |
|
| |
♥Q4 |
|
| |
♦AK43 |
|
| |
♣10 |
|